Citing references
Opinions citing Bute v. Potts, 18 P. 329 (Cal. 1888)
8 citing cases
-
235 N.W.2d 187 Supreme Court of MinnesotaSeptember 26, 1975
S. 601 (1927); Bute v. Potts, 76 Cal. 304 , 18 P. 329 (1888); Brown v. Shyne, 242 N. Y. 176 , 151 N. E. 197 (1926). Cf. In re Tug Management Corp. 330 F. Supp. 486 *426 (E. D. Pa. 1971). But see, Whipple v. Grandchamp, 261 Mass. 40 , 158 N.
-
497 P.2d 1354 Hawaii Supreme CourtJune 2, 1972
App.2d 85, 93-94 , 338 P.2d 607, 611-12 (1959); Bute v. Potts, 76 Cal. 304, 305 , 18 P. 329 (1888). In the present case, Dr.
-
105 N.E. 178 Indiana Court of AppealsMay 15, 1914
Potts (1888), 76 Cal. 304 , 18 Pac. 329 ; Holtzman v. Hoy (1886), 118 Ill. 534 , 8 N. E. 832 , 59 Am. Rep. 390 . 12. 20. We have examined the questions presented in relation to the evidence and instructions given and refused and find no reversible error.
-
338 P.2d 607 California Court of AppealMay 1, 1959
Potts (1888), 76 Cal. 304 [ 18 P. 329 ], There the defendant physician was unlicensed and the court declared: “The fact that he had or had not certificates and diplomas as a physician and surgeon is no proof either that he had skill as such or lacked it.
-
8 So. 2d 37 Supreme Court of FloridaMay 8, 1942
Bute v. *Page 541 Potts, 76 Cal. 304 , 18 P. 329 ; Holtzman v. Hay, 118 Ill. 534 , 8 N.E. 832 , 59 Am. ap. 390." Spearman Redfield on the law of Negligence, Vol. 3 (6th Ed.) pages 1629-30, par. 614A, say: ". . .
-
197 S.W.2d 798 Tennessee Supreme CourtNovember 30, 1946
In Bute v. Potts, 76 Cal. 304 , 18 P. 329 , the Court said: “. . . A certificate or diploma could be no proof that he (defendant) acted with skill in attending a given patient, or that he did not so act.
-
37 L.R.A. 830 Supreme Court of IowaApril 10, 1897 Dissent
Bute v. Potts, 76 Cal. 304 . The fact thata doctor is reputed to be negligent and uuskilful cannot be allowed as proof to establish negligence or unskilful treatment in a particular case, Stevenson v. Gelsthorpe, 10 Mont. 563 . X. Who judges of shill.
-
187 S.E. 788 Supreme Court of North CarolinaOctober 14, 1936
Bute v. Potts, 76 Cal., 304 ; Janssen v. Mulder, 232 Mich., 183 .