Hargett v. Delisle
H. C. Hargett v. Alfred Delisle and Wife, Mary Eleanor Delisle.
Opinion of the Court
Devin, J.
Notwithstanding there veas a clause in the contract providing for arbitration of any disagreement arising out of the contract, the parties have elected to settle their differences in the law courts. The plaintiff has brought his action in the Superior Court and has filed notice of lien in accordance with the statute. The defendants have accepted the challenge in that tribunal, and filed answer denying indebtedness and setting up a cross-action. They ask affirmative relief in the Superior Court against the plaintiff. It is apparent that the parties have chosen to ignore and waive the provision as to arbitration. Neither has referred to it in the pleadings or asked that this method of settling the matters in controversy be employed. 117 A. L. R., 308, and cases cited.
The jurisdiction of the Superior Court invoked by both parties may not thus be abrogated over the objection of one whose relief for the cause alleged is now available in the manner he has pursued. Whether in any event, by a previously executed contract to arbitrate, the jurisdiction of the Superior Court could be ousted on motion of one of the parties after suit began is not presently presented.
Braddy v. Ins. Co., 115 N. C., 354 , 20 S. E., 477 ;
Kelly v. Trimont Lodge, 154 N. C., 97 , 69 S. E., 764 ;
Williams v. Mfg. Co., 154 N. C., 205 , 70 S. E., 290 ;
Cordell v. Brotherhood, 208 N. C., 632 (639), 182 S. E., 141 ;
Blodgett v. Bebe, 214 Pac., 38 , 26 A. L. R., 1070; 3 Am. Jur., 871 . See also Copney v. Parks, 212 N. C., 217 , 193 S. E., 21 ; 135 A. L. R., 79.
*386 There was error in dismissing the action. The judgment below should be vacated and the cause restored to the docket for trial by appropriate procedure.
Reversed.
How later courts describe this case
Explanatory parentheticals written by citing courts — 2 in all; the most informative distinct ones are shown.
-
(once the parties have invoked the jurisdiction of the court by complaint and responsive pleadings, the court may not order them to arbitrate pursuant to prior agreement)
Cited by 8 cases
View all citing references →Relies on it most ⓘ
Citing references are not a citator: they show that a later opinion cites this case, not whether it followed, distinguished, or overruled it. Check negative history before relying on this case.