TaiLexi AI U.S. Case Law

Uncle Sam Oil Co. v. Richards

Uncle Sam Oil Co. v. Richards, 1918 OK 529, 176 P. 240
Download
Format
Include

Star paging (*137) is kept for pin cites.

Court
Supreme Court of Oklahoma · State Highest Courts
Decided
September 17, 1918
Docket
No. 9034
Judges
Pryor
Citations
176 P. 2401918 OK 52973 Okla. 3281918 Okla. LEXIS 145
Disposition
Affirmed.
Syllabus
1. Appleal and Error — Review — Setting Asidei Default Judgment. Where there has been a trial of a cause in the absence of a party or default judgment rendered, and no objections and exceptions saved, the rulings of the court in the trial of said cause cannot be reviewed on appeal. 2. Judgment — Default Judgment — Vacation. It is not the duty of the court clerk to notify a party or his attorney of the setting of a cause for trial, and the failure to do so is not grounds to vacate a judgment rendered in the absence of such party or his attorney. (Syllabus by Pryor, .Q.)
Summary
Error from District Court, Tulsa County; Conn Linn, Judge. Action by’ A. M. Richards against the Uncle Sam Oil Company. Default judgment for plaintiff, petition to set aside the judgment denied, and defendant brings error.

Syllabus and headnotes are prepared by the reporter or publisher, not the court, and are not part of the opinion.

Opinion of the Court — Pryor

Opinion by PRYOR, O.

This is an action by A. M. Richards against the Unde Sam Oil Company, to recover under a contract for developing pertain oil and gas leases in Payne county.

The defendant company answered in said cause, the cause came on for trial on the 2d day of December, 1015, and the defendant failed to appear and make defense, and there was trial of said caiise in its' absence, and judgment rendered for the plaintiff in the sum of '$3,759-.48 on the 17th day of April, 1916. ■ ■ The defendant company filed a petition in said cause to have said judgment set aside, and that it be granted a new trial in said cause on the grounds of unavoidable casualty which prevented the defendant' from appearing and making a'defense to the plaintiff’s action. The petition to set aside the judgment was denied by the trial court, and the defendant company appealed.

The defendant on appeal here urges several assignments of error alleged to have been committed by the trial court in the trial of said cause. Where there has been a trial of a cause in the absence of a party or default judgment rendered, and there is no exception saved to the action of a trial court in the trial of said cause, the same cannot be reviewed on appeal, unless the questions raised are jurisdictional. Martindale v. Beattey, 73 Kan. 94 , 84 Pac. 527 ; Johnson v. Jones, 58 Kan. 745 , 51 Pac. 224 .

All of the evidence taken on the hearing to vacate the judgment is not preserved in the record. The principal grounds relied upon for the vacation of the judgment is that the clerk neglected to notify attorneys for the defendant that the cause was set for trial.

The .evidence shows that the attorney for the defendant, ,v\ho resides in Kansas City, Mo., communicated by letter on -several different occasions with the clerk of the court, regarding the time when said cause would come up for trial, also once by telephone. The last communication that counsel for the defendant had with the clerk in regard to the setting of said cause for trial was on the 27th day, of May, 1915, and the cause was set for trial, and heard on the 2d day of December, 1915. Between the two dates neither-the attorney for the defendant, nor the defendant, made any inquiry or any effort to ascertain when the cause would be set for trial. The failure of the clerk to notify a party- for his' attorney that a cause is set for trial is not a ground -under the statutes for the vacating or setting aside-of a judgment rendered in his absence. North v. Hooker, 68 Okla. 106 , 172 Pac. 77 ; Western Goal & Mine Company v. Green, 64 Okla. 53 , 166 Pac. 154 .

The facts as disclosed by tie record héf.e tend rather to show that the defendant' 'or its counsel had not used due diligence in .keeping informed as to the setting of ¿aid caiise for trial and the trial '.tHfefeof iind its want of proper diligence in ¿pp'etóng and defending said cause.’ The- -trial court 'did not .abuse its discretion in "-'rfef using to Vacate and set aside said, judgment. , Therefore the judgment .of the, trial court refusing to set aside its" former' judgment should be affirme d .

By the Court: It is so ordered.'

How later courts describe this case

No later court has written an explanatory parenthetical about this case yet.

1920: 11922: 11925: 21926: 11934: 11935: 219202026peak 1925 · 2

Relies on it most ⓘ

  1. Eagle Loan & Inv. Co. v. Turner1925 OK 672, 241 P. 138
  2. Johnson v. Bearden Plumbing & Heating Co.1934 OK 677, 38 P.2d 500
  3. Mid-Texas Petroleum Co. v. Western Lumber & Hdwe. Co.1935 OK 899, 52 P.2d 15
  4. Colley v. Sapp1922 OK 131, 216 P. 454
  5. Hawkins v. Central Foundry Co.1935 OK 1041, 50 P.2d 685
  6. McCandless v. Childs1925 OK 637, 239 P. 254

Most recent

  1. Hawkins v. Central Foundry Co.1935 OK 1041, 50 P.2d 685
  2. Mid-Texas Petroleum Co. v. Western Lumber & Hdwe. Co.1935 OK 899, 52 P.2d 15
  3. Johnson v. Bearden Plumbing & Heating Co.1934 OK 677, 38 P.2d 500
  4. Quadrangle Petroleum Co. v. Western Drilling Co.1926 OK 768, 251 P. 1004
  5. Eagle Loan & Inv. Co. v. Turner1925 OK 672, 241 P. 138
  6. McCandless v. Childs1925 OK 637, 239 P. 254

Citing references are not a citator: they show that a later opinion cites this case, not whether it followed, distinguished, or overruled it. Check negative history before relying on this case.

Authorities cited 4

DepthCaseCited by
Martindale v. Battey, 84 P. 527 (Kan. 1906) 23
Johnson v. Jones, 51 P. 224 (Kan. 1897) 14
Western Coal & Mining Co. v. Green, 1917 OK 280, 166 P. 154 12
North v. Hooker, 1918 OK 193, 172 P. 77 10

Keyboard shortcuts

/Focus the search box
j kNext / previous result
EnterOpen the selected result
xAdd / remove the selected result from the download list
n pNext / previous search term in a case
cCopy the citation of the current case
+ −Larger / smaller reading text
?Show this list