TaiLexi AI U.S. Case Law

Ex Parte Barton

Ex Parte LOREN BARTON Et Al.

Ex Parte Barton, 1925 OK CR 483, 239 P. 944
Download
Format
Include

Star paging (*137) is kept for pin cites.

Court
Court of Criminal Appeals of Oklahoma · State Appellate Courts
Decided
October 17, 1925
Docket
No. A-5532.
Judges
Bessey, Doy'Le, Edwaeds
Citations
239 P. 9441925 OK CR 48332 Okla. Crim. 411925 Okla. Crim. App. LEXIS 463

Opinion of the Court — Bessey

BESSEY, P. J.

The petitioners at this time are each serving sentences of 5 years in the Oklahoma state reformatory at Granite for automobile larceny. ' In this application petitioners attack the jurisdiction of the district court of Woodward county to impose the sentences of conviction. The petitioners were each 18 years of age, and say that on the 27th day of August, 1924, an information was filed in the district court charging them with larceny; that on the same day they were taken before the district court, where they waived their right to counsel and entered their separate pleas of guilty to the charge. At this point the record shows the following:

“And now, the time having arrived for the court to announce judgment and sentence against the defendants, *43 the court asks the defendants if they have any legal cause to show why judgment and sentence should not be pronounced against them.”

The defendants offered no objections, and judgment was thereupon pronounced; this being on the same day on which their pleas of guilty were received.

In this state a minor over the age of 16 years is presumed to be responsible for his criminal acts. The time of infancy is usually divided into three parts, during each of which a different presumption as to criminal responsibility prevails. Children under the age of 7 years are conclusively presumed to be incapable of committing crime; children over the age of 7 years and under the age of 16 years are presumed to be incapable of committing crime, except where it is affirmatively shown in a juvenile proceeding that the child knew or comprehended the wrongfulness of his act or acts. Over the age of 16 the infant is presumed to know the consequences and import of his criminal acts, and to be responsible therefor. In some cases this may be a rebut-table presumption, but the burden of proving incapacity during this period is on the infant defendant. State v. Di Guglielmo, 4 Pennewill, 336 , 55 A. 350 ; State v. Kavanaugh, 3 Pennewill, 131 , 53 A. 335 .

It follows, therefore, that there is no difference in the mode of procedure in a criminal case against a defendant 18 years of age and a defendant who has reached his majority. An 18-year-old defendant may waive his right to counsel, may plead guilty, and may waive the statutory time to pronounce judgment. The record here ¡shows that these defendants did waive {the right to counsel, and did plead guilty. It has been held by this and other courts that, in the absence of a record to the contrary, a waiver of the time to pronounce judgment *44 will be presumed. Jones v. Ter., 4 Okla. 45 , 43 P. 1072 . Williams v. State, 17 Okla. Cr. 452 , 190 P. 892 .

Courts in dealing with minors of the age of 18 years charged with a felony, where such minors appear without counsel, parent, or friend, should carefully guard their constitutional and statutory rights in all matters of procedure. Under such circumstances it would seem appropriate for the court to exercise the duties in the nature of a guardian for minor defendants in order that no injustice may inadvertently result. But a failure to so safeguard the rights of accused minors, while it might amount to reversible error on an appeal, will not be sufficient to deprive the trial court of its jurisdiction over such minors so as to give the accused a remedy by habeas corpus in this court.

To determine whether these petitioners have a right to relief by habeas corpus this court must first consider whether the court which rendered the judgment had jurisdiction of the subject-matter and of the persons, and whether during the course of the proceedings the trial court lost jurisdiction of either. Ex parte Hill, 12 Okla. Cr. 335 , 156 P. 686 ; Ex parte Lyde, 17 Okla. Cr. 618 , 191 P. 606 .

We hold that a minor 18 years of age may waive his right to counsel, plead guilty, and be proceeded against subsequently as in other cases. Ex parte White, 50 Tex. Cr. R. 473 , 98 S. W. 850 ; People v. Wandell, 21 Hun (N. Y.) 515. Here the trial court had jurisdiction of the person and the subject-matter, and there is no showing that such jurisdiction was- lost in the course of the proceedings.

The application for the writ is denied.

DOY'LE and EDWAEDS, JJ., concur.

How later courts describe this case

No later court has written an explanatory parenthetical about this case yet.

1942: 11943: 11956: 11970: 11972: 119422026peak 1942 · 1

Relies on it most ⓘ

  1. Freshour v. Turner1972 OK CR 108, 496 P.2d 389
  2. Jackson v. State460 S.W.2d 319 (Ark. 1970)
  3. Ex Parte Nye1942 OK CR 129, 129 P.2d 614
  4. Application of McDaniel1956 OK CR 104, 302 P.2d 496
  5. Ex Parte Noble1943 OK CR 136, 144 P.2d 122

Most recent

  1. Freshour v. Turner1972 OK CR 108, 496 P.2d 389
  2. Jackson v. State460 S.W.2d 319 (Ark. 1970)
  3. Application of McDaniel1956 OK CR 104, 302 P.2d 496
  4. Ex Parte Noble1943 OK CR 136, 144 P.2d 122
  5. Ex Parte Nye1942 OK CR 129, 129 P.2d 614

Citing references are not a citator: they show that a later opinion cites this case, not whether it followed, distinguished, or overruled it. Check negative history before relying on this case.

Authorities cited 6

DepthCaseCited by
Ex Parte Lyde, 1920 OK CR 150, 191 P. 606 23
Jones v. Territory of Okla., 43 P. 1072 (Okla. 1896) 21
Ex Parte White, 98 S.W. 850 (Tex. Crim. App. 1906) 16
Williams v. State, 1919 OK CR 302, 190 P. 892 11
In re Hill, 1916 OK CR 38, 156 P. 686 7
State v. Kavanaugh, 53 A. 335 (1902) 9

Keyboard shortcuts

/Focus the search box
j kNext / previous result
EnterOpen the selected result
xAdd / remove the selected result from the download list
n pNext / previous search term in a case
cCopy the citation of the current case
+ −Larger / smaller reading text
?Show this list