TaiLexi AI U.S. Case Law

Gill's Estate

Gill's Estate.

Gill's Estate, 171 A. 457 (Pa. 1934)
Download
Format
Include

Star paging (*137) is kept for pin cites.

Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · State Highest Courts
Decided
January 17, 1934
Docket
Nos. , 34
Judges
Frazer, Simpson, Kephart, Schaerer, Maxey, Drew, Linn
Citations
171 A. 457314 Pa. 5581934 Pa. LEXIS 540

Opinion of the Court — Per Curiam

Per Curiam, This case is before us on appeal from a decree of the Orphans’ Court of Montgomery County dismissing exceptions to the adjudication in the estate of Jessie L. Gill, deceased. Appellant seeks to recover part of the proceeds of a number of policies of insurance on the life of her husband, R. Walter Peterson, paid at his death to the estate of Jessie L. Gill, who in her lifetime had received the policies by assignment from the estate of Harrison S. Gill, her husband. The policies in question were held by decedent’s estate under the terms of written instruments providing for an absolute sale of the policies, together with the interests of Peterson and his mother *560 in designated life estates, to Gill for a consideration of $6,800. The claim is presented on the theory that the policies were conveyed to Gill as security for the repayment of a loan, and appellant seeks to introduce evidence of an oral agreement varying the written contracts to that effect.

The principle is firmly established that evidence of a parol agreement is not admissible to alter or vary the terms of a written instrument, complete in itself, except where omitted through fraud, accident or mistake: Speier v. Michelson, 303 Pa. 66 . Appellant recognizes the force and effect of the Parol Evidence Rule and makes no claim to come within the exceptions just stated, but argues that the question involved in this case “is whether the facts bring it within that class of cases where the court has permitted, as a matter of public policy, parol evidence to show the true facts regardless of the provisions of the written agreement.” Counsel has cited no case, however, in which such a principle of public policy has been applied under facts analogous to those before us now.

The deed of sale by which the insurance policies here involved were conveyed to Gill is clear and unambiguous, and expressly states: “It is distinctly understood and agreed that this transaction constitutes an absolute sale of the interest of the parties of the first and second parts.” To admit evidence of a parol agreement making the transaction merely a transfer of the policies as security for a loan would be not only to make nugatory the provisions of the written contract, but completely to re-: write the instrument for the parties. This we have no authority to do. See Architectural Tile Co. v. McSorley, 311 Pa. 299 .

The decree is affirmed at cost of appellant.

How later courts describe this case

No later court has written an explanatory parenthetical about this case yet.

1936: 11937: 11938: 11949: 11950: 119362026peak 1936 · 1

Relies on it most ⓘ

  1. Biddle v. Biddle70 A.2d 281 (Pa. 1949)
  2. Biddle v. BIDDLE363 Pa. 426 (1950)
  3. Collins v. Horn188 A. 87 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1936)
  4. Gibbons' Estate200 A. 55 (Pa. 1938)
  5. Gibbons' Estate29 Pa. D. & C. 545 (1937)

Most recent

  1. Biddle v. BIDDLE363 Pa. 426 (1950)
  2. Biddle v. Biddle70 A.2d 281 (Pa. 1949)
  3. Gibbons' Estate200 A. 55 (Pa. 1938)
  4. Gibbons' Estate29 Pa. D. & C. 545 (1937)
  5. Collins v. Horn188 A. 87 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1936)

Citing references are not a citator: they show that a later opinion cites this case, not whether it followed, distinguished, or overruled it. Check negative history before relying on this case.

Authorities cited 2

DepthCaseCited by
Speier v. Michelson, 154 A. 127 (Pa. 1931) 82
Architectural Tile Co. v. McSorley, 166 A. 913 (Pa. 1933) 12

Keyboard shortcuts

/Focus the search box
j kNext / previous result
EnterOpen the selected result
xAdd / remove the selected result from the download list
n pNext / previous search term in a case
cCopy the citation of the current case
+ −Larger / smaller reading text
?Show this list