TaiLexi AI U.S. Case Law

Manley's Case

Mary J. Manley's Case

Manley's Case, 184 N.E. 372 (Mass. 1933)
Download
Format
Include

Star paging (*137) is kept for pin cites.

Court
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · State Highest Courts
Decided
February 14, 1933
Judges
Lummus
Citations
184 N.E. 372282 Mass. 381933 Mass. LEXIS 843

Opinion of the Court — Lummus

Text extracted by OCR from a scanned original; check the original for exact wording.

Lummus, J.

On June 26,1929, the employee, a comptometer operator, lost the ends of three fingers of her right hand while cutting time cards in the course of her employment for the Bethlehem Shipbuilding Corporation, Ltd. She was paid specific compensation under G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 152, § 36, and also weekly compensation until December 1, 1929, when she resumed her former work for the same corporation. *39 She was unable to work as well as before, because her fingers were tender and blunted. On October 31, 1931, she was discharged for lack of work, and has been unable to get work since, although she has diligently sought other employment. The Industrial Accident Board awarded weekly compensation for partial incapacity since October 31, 1931, and the Superior Court entered a decree accordingly. The insurer appealed.

Compensation cannot be awarded for lack of employment due to depressed business or want of demand for labor; diminished earning capacity resulting from the injury must be shown. Korobchuk’s Case, 277 Mass. 534 . Lavallee’s Case, 277 Mass. 538 . Riley’s Case, 278 Mass. 257 . But the finding that the employee’s failure to get work was due in part to “incapacity for work resulting from the injury” (G. L. [Ter. Ed.] c. 152, § 35) is not without some support in the evidence. Her hand is obviously maimed, and that fact, without further evidence (O’Reilly’s Case, 265 Mass. 456 ; Percival’s Case, 268 Mass. 50, 54 ), warrants a conclusion that in many lines of business she would be under a handicap, not only in working (Morrell’s Case, 278 Mass. 485 ; Hurwitz’s Case, 280 Mass. 477 ), but also in obtaining work. Sullivan’s Case, 218 Mass. 141 . Duprey’s Case, 219 Mass. 189 . Lacione’s Case, 227 Mass. 269 . Capone’s Case, 239 Mass. 331 . Hurwitz’s Case, 280 Mass. 477 . The employee testified that, in one of the places at which she applied unsuccessfully for employment, she noticed that her hand was being observed.

Decree affirmed.

How later courts describe this case

No later court has written an explanatory parenthetical about this case yet.

1934: 21935: 11939: 21942: 11945: 11950: 219342026peak 1934 · 2

Relies on it most ⓘ

  1. Hummer's Case59 N.E.2d 295 (Mass. 1945)
  2. Clark v. Henry & Wright Manufacturing Co.72 A.2d 489 (Conn. 1950)
  3. Doherty v. Ruiz18 N.E.2d 542 (Mass. 1939)
  4. Pierce's Case92 N.E.2d 245 (Mass. 1950)
  5. Akins's Case20 N.E.2d 453 (Mass. 1939)
  6. Fennell's Case193 N.E. 885 (Mass. 1935)

Most recent

  1. Pierce's Case92 N.E.2d 245 (Mass. 1950)
  2. Clark v. Henry & Wright Manufacturing Co.72 A.2d 489 (Conn. 1950)
  3. Hummer's Case59 N.E.2d 295 (Mass. 1945)
  4. Whitehead's Case45 N.E.2d 839 (Mass. 1942)
  5. Akins's Case20 N.E.2d 453 (Mass. 1939)
  6. Doherty v. Ruiz18 N.E.2d 542 (Mass. 1939)

Citing references are not a citator: they show that a later opinion cites this case, not whether it followed, distinguished, or overruled it. Check negative history before relying on this case.

Authorities cited 11

DepthCaseCited by
Hurwitz's Case, 182 N.E. 832 (Mass. 1932) 9
Sullivan's Case, 218 Mass. 141 (1914) 43
Duprey's Case, 219 Mass. 189 (1914) 29
Percival's Case, 167 N.E. 352 (Mass. 1929) 25
Capone's Case, 239 Mass. 331 (1921) 23
Korobchuk's Case, 179 N.E. 175 (Mass. 1931) 18
Lacione's Case, 227 Mass. 269 (1917) 15
O'Reilly's Case, 265 Mass. 456 (1929) 15
Morrell's Case, 180 N.E. 223 (Mass. 1932) 5
Riley's Case, 179 N.E. 690 (Mass. 1932) 4
Lavallee's Case, 179 N.E. 214 (Mass. 1931) 3

Keyboard shortcuts

/Focus the search box
j kNext / previous result
EnterOpen the selected result
xAdd / remove the selected result from the download list
n pNext / previous search term in a case
cCopy the citation of the current case
+ −Larger / smaller reading text
?Show this list