State ex rel. Griffith v. Bone

The opinion of the court was delivered by Harvey, J.:

In a posi-opinion motion, plaintiff asks whether the liability, to the extent of its bonds or money pledged, of a member bank which withdraws from the guaranty act, or which liquidates its affairs, is measured, (1) by certificates actually issued on the bank depositors’ guaranty fund at the date of such withdrawal or liquidation; or (2) by the liability of the bank depositors’ guaranty fund to depositors of member banks, which had previously failed, whether or not certificates have been issued to such depositors?

*152 When a member bank fails* and is taken charge of by the bank commissioner, the statute (R. S. 9-204, Laws 1925, ch. 88) contemplates, that certificates to depositors shall be issued “at the earliest moment” for the amount of their respective deposits, upon the bank depositors’ guaranty fund. Naturally this cannot, in all cases, be done at once. Each claim for such a certificate requires investigation. Some may require litigation, with the result that several weeks or months may elapse after the date of the failure of the member bank before certificates are actually issued to all depositors of such bank. When issued, it is proper that they be issued as of date of the bank’s failure (Songer v. Bank Commissioner, 114 Kan. 900, 903 , 220 Pac. 1060 ). If, pending the issuance of such certificates, a member bank should withdraw (under second paragraph R. S. 9-205) or cease to be a member bank by liquidation (under R. S. 9-209), it is liable for assessments necessary to replenish the bank depositors’ guaranty fund, to the extent of its bonds, or money, pledged for the payment of certificates drawn on that fund issued or issuable to depositors of member banks which had failed prior to the date such withdrawal, or liquidation, became effective, whether or not such certificates had been in fact issued.

In other words, in determining the question, the date of the actual issuance of the certificate is not material. But two dates are necessary to be considered — the date of the failure of the member bank, to the depositors of which certificates are later issued, and the date of withdrawal or liquidation of the bank whose bonds or money pledged are in question.