Hosp v. Civil Service Commission

The opinion of the court was delivered by Gummere, Chief Justice.

This writ is sued out to test the validity of a resolution of the civil service commission of the State of New Jersey’ placing in the classified service, and classifying in the competitive class of the civil service, the position of warden of the Essex county penitentiary. Under the Civil Service act all officers, clerks and emploj^es in the service of the state or of any municipality in which the statute' is in force who are properly placed in the classified service by the civil service commission are entitled to hold their offices and employments indefinitely, and are not subject to removal therefrom except for cause; and the question presented for determination is whether under the statute referred to the commission is legalty justified in placing the office of warden of the county jail in the classified service.

*11 in the case of Attorney-General v. McGuinness, 49 Vroom 346 , 385, which was a proceeding in the nature of a quo warranto to test the question whether the office of county collector was one which could be placed in the classified service by the-civil service commission and thereby made subject to the provisions of the Civil Service law, it was determined by the trial justice that the act did not apply to the ease of offices whose-terms are established by law, and that conclusion was affirmed by the Court of Errors and Appeals, that court saying, “the-construction placed upon the act by Mr. Justice Swayze, in the Supreme Court, in so far as the office in dispute is concerned, meets with our approval.”

By the provisions of “An act to reorganize the government of counties of the first class in this state,” approved March 22d, 1900 (Vamph. L., p. 168), the hoards of chosen freeholders in such counties are required to appoint, among other officers, a warden of the penitentiary (section 6); and by the- provision of the eleventh section of that act the term of that office is fixed at Iwo years; and no statute to which my attention has been called or with which I am familiar has so modified the provision of section 11 as- to change the term of this-office from a fixed and definite one to an indefinite one. It follows, therefore, that as the office of warden of the county penitentiary in a county of the first class is one the term of' which is fixed and established hv law the incumbent thereof is not a fleeted by the provisions of the Civil Service law and cannot, by any action of the civil service commission, be retained in his office after the expiration of his fixed term.

I conclude, therefore, that the resolution of the ci.vil service-commission brought up for review by this writ should be set aside.